What is a Good Return in Commercial Real Estate?

Consider these factors before you make a new investment.

What is a Good Return in Commercial Real Estate?

Consider these factors before you make a new investment.

When learning about a new real estate opportunity, one of your first questions is probably, “What’s the projected ROI?” But how do you determine whether an ROI is high enough?

Unfortunately, like most questions in real estate, the answer to this is not cut and dry. Commercial real estate returns vary depending on a wide variety of factors, and a “good” ROI for one property might not be “good” for another.

Here are some of the important things to consider when evaluating the expected ROI of a new real estate investment.

How is ROI Calculated?

Put simply, ROI is the expected returns from the investment minus the cost of the investment, divided by the cost of the investment.

To calculate your ROI for a real estate investment:

  1. Calculate the expected annual rental income
  2. Subtract rental expenses from annual rental income
  3. Compute your % share of the net income
  4. Divide your net income by your total investment

According to the S&P 500 Index, the average annual return on investment for commercial real estate is 9.5%, though it’s important to remember that this number can vary significantly depending on the asset class.

How to Determine if An Investment is Worthwhile

Once you have calculated the potential ROI of a deal, you’ll then need to decide whether or not it’s an investment worth making. To help you do this, we recommend asking yourself the following three questions:

1. Is this specific opportunity suitable for me?

Consider the location. Do you believe buildings or developments in this market will maintain or increase their value in the next 5-10 years? How does the ROI for this property compare to similar properties in the same market?

You should also consider your personal risk tolerance. In many cases, a higher expected ROI will translate to a higher level of risk, and a lower ROI may indicate a lower risk investment.

2. What do the rent roll and weighted average lease term tell me about this property?

By evaluating the rent roll, you can learn crucial information about the property’s current leases, projected future income, and level of risk. For example, if there are multiple leases set to expire around the same time, or if vacancy rates are unusually high, this could increase your risk.

Rent rolls will also help you calculate the gross income you expect the property to generate, and to identify opportunities to increase that gross income in the future.

If the weighted average lease term (the average amount of lease time remaining for current tenants given the tenant size), is 3-4 years or higher that will typically indicate a level of stability for the investment.

3. Does the investment strategy make sense?

Almost any building can be a good investment, but it all depends on the strategy chosen by the deal sponsor. This is why it’s so important to work with an experienced sponsor who you trust and who has a proven track record of success.

Does the sponsor’s plan make sense to you? Are they transparent about the strategy and the concrete steps they’ll take to achieve it? Are you comfortable with the leverage point included in their model? If the assumptions in the strategy make sense and are suitable for the building and its location, then you’re generally on the right track.

Consider These Metrics Alongside the ROI

By looking at multiple data points, you can gain a fuller picture of the profitability of an investment. Instead of only paying attention to the expected ROI, look also at:

Capitalization Rate: A property’s cap rate is the annual, debt-free rate of return from a property, based on its annual net operating income and current property value.

Internal Rate of Return: IRR measures the annual ROI over a particular time period, rather than over the total time of ownership

Cash-on-Cash Return: This calculation compares the annual pre-tax cash flow from a property to the total amount of cash invested.

At Excelsior Capital, we focus on investing in stable asset classes in healthy secondary markets, and this strategy has delivered consistently strong returns for our investors. If you’re interested in learning more about our direct co-investment opportunities, please fill out this brief form to get in touch with a member of our team.

Previous Articles


The Ultimate Guide to Commercial Real Estate Investing

Learn everything you need to know to assess the benefits of a commercial real estate investment and make the best decisions to get started.


Q1 2023 Commercial Real Estate Investment Update

The commercial real estate industry has seen significant shifts and challenges over the past year, and the first quarter of 2023 was no exception.

Understanding the Waterfall Structure in Real Estate Private Equity Investments

Understanding the Waterfall Structure in Real Estate Private Equity Investments

Learn about this distribution framework used in real estate private equity investments. Understand the components of a waterfall structure…


How Much Money Do I Need to Start Investing in Commercial Real Estate?

We frequently have conversations where people tell us, “I want to start investing in commercial real estate, but I’m not sure if I have the capital.”


Benefits of Owning Commercial Property over Residential

While both types of real estate investments have their benefits, investing in CRE can be more advantageous for several reasons.

The Revolution That Wasn’t

How has technology impacted modern finance and created an asymmetrical relationship between Wall Street and individual investors? In this episode, we speak with Spencer Jakab, the author of The Revolution That Wasn’t and editor of the Wall Street Journal’s Heard on the Street column.

Tax Savings Secrets: How Cost Segregation Analysis Can Save You Money

How can cost segregation analysis help real estate investors maximize their returns? In this episode, John Hanning explores the potential benefits of cost recovery studies and depreciation.

What is a Family Owner’s Manual and Do I Need One?

It’s time to make sure you and your family are set up to continue success for generations to come. Today, Josh Kanter shares his journey transitioning from practice as a transactional attorney to reorganizing his family’s activities under a single-family office.

Key Characteristics of High-Performing Family Offices

Are family offices becoming more popular? In this episode, Robert Daugherty dives into the importance of having a functional family office, and the role of the Chief Learning Officer in it.

Excelsior Capital

A real estate private equity firm that owns and operates high quality multi-tenant office assets in emerging secondary markets.

Interested in learning more about Excelsior's investment opportunities?

Excelsior Capital

104 Woodmont Blvd, Suite 120
Nashville, TN 37205




Disclaimer: Under no circumstances should any information presented on this website be construed as an offer to sell, or solicitation of an offer to purchase any securities or other investments. This website does not contain the information that an investor should consider or evaluate to make a potential investment. Other materials related to investments in entities managed by Excelsior Capital are not available to the general public.